SHARE YOUR REVIEW OF PONY ISLAND!

by Sydney
(HorseCrazyGirls.com)

Pony Island is a cute game with fantasy horses. You can read my review of Pony Island here.

Here you'll find reviews and tips from other girls who play this online horse game. Share yours!

Read this before you share or comment on this site.

Comments for SHARE YOUR REVIEW OF PONY ISLAND!

Average Rating

Click here to add your own comments

Rating

Pony Island?
by: Alisha

A few years ago, I was randomly typing websites, and I fell upon ponyisland.com and howrse.com. I made accounts for both. I didn't understand either, but loved all of my horses all the same.

Then I found out that my time on pony island expired. You only get a limited time on pony island but howrse is endless.

On howrse, you can restart your game if you make a mistake, like letting a filly or foal die or accidentally fixing your stallion. You can even quit howrse (though I never would).

You can make your horse immortal or stumble on age points (1 age pt ages your horse by 2 months). If you leave your howrse alone, nothing happens. It does not age or anything else. So I recommend howrse!

Rating

Pony Island
by: Anonymous

It's cool, but quite boring and there's really nothing to pay for on it. You don't even interact with anything there. I suggest Star Stable to everyone, even though it does get a little boring after a while if you don't have star membership, but the membership is actually worth it.

Rating

Pony Island ROXS!
by: Annie

Awesome place to experience ponies! I would rate it 10 out of 10.

Rating

Pony Island is Cool
by: Hannah

It's so good for riding. You learn everything there is to know about horses in a second. And the cutest horses I think is Gypsy because she always listens to whatever I say and she is so kind.

Rating

Pony Island is AWESOME!
by: Bella

It is a safe game and it is really fun to play by yourself and with friends too!

Rating

PI is so EPIC!
by: Anonymous

I have been playing for almost two years and it's the best thing ever! There are adoptables, and lots of different ponies. But don't play PI if you are immature, because if you act immaturely on the forums, then nobody will like you. It is a quite mature website with standards and rules.

Rating

Pony Island is worth paying for!
by: Lily

The fact that you have to pay stops annoying advertisements and makes it more of a community unlike websites like Neopets. Pony Island is amazing!

Rating

Pony Island Rocks
by: Isabelle

Pony Island is awesome other than it is a pay site. You get 20 days free, then you have to pay. Other than that, it rocks!

Rating

It could be a lot better
by: Debby

I'm sorry, but I think Pony Island could be a lot better. I really like the game. I tried it for 20 days but I can't afford to pay my hard-earned cash to play the game. I think they should make it like where you can play for free as well. :D

Rating

Pony Island: Great Game!
by: Sam

Pony Island is great! I made a lovely foal called Comet and he rocks just like that game! Whoo-hoo! Join this game, it’s great!

Rating

Pony Island is coolio
by: Mia

I think that Pony Island is fun when you make the pony but there isn't many more fun things to do after. I would recommend Club Pony Pals.

Rating

Pony island is AWESOME
by: Lizzie

It sounds fun and I really, really want to play it. I hope I'm going to love this games also because I love horses and little foals too. Horses are my favorite animals and that is why I'm here, because I love horses and this game really got my interest. I love the way it sounds so terrific and fantastic so I'm really looking forward to this game.

Rating

Pony Island is the Best!
by: Rayne

At first I thought Pony Island (PI) was a little confusing. There's a whole new language to learn, and people to get used to. After you get used to it, even trying to figure it out, it turns out to be really fun! The ponies are so beautiful, and there are so many types of magical breeds, like unicorns, fairies, nixies, valks, dragons, purrs, kirins, mermaid ponies, and so much more! I really enjoy it, and I'm gonna be playing for a long time!

Rating

Pony Island
by: Michelle

Well, I just started this game and it seems kind of boring but I'm sure (according to all you pony island fans) it will be good after a bit. I just got my new foal and its cute and all but I can't do anything with it but look at it. Oh well, it's only a baby and I bet I will be able to do more things with it when it gets older. Lotsa waiting!

Rating

It's addicting!
by: Heatherly

Pony Island is probably one of the most addicting games I've played online. That said, it's such a cute game with lots of color and friendly people! I've been playing for over a year now and love it. :)

Rating

Cute pony colts
by: Tessa Sue

It feels really fun to have a horse online!

Rating

Pony Island is awesome!
by: Hannah

Pony Island is one of the best games I have ever played. I created the cutest pony EVER! You create the mum and dad and they have a baby and that's your pony. My pony is called Starheart.

Rating

It's OK!!!
by: Chanel

Pony Island is kinda cool but also sometimes boring!

Rating

Pony Island is awesome!
by: Jazz

Really fun and I would go there again. It's like being in a real life place. I loved it!

Rating

REAL MONEY???
by: SYDNEY

I found out you had to pay to play! It is not free to keep it online.

Rating

Pony island is so cool
by: Olivia

It’s so much better than howrse. It’s COOL!!!

Rating

Pony Island is OK
by: Elise

I thought pony island was going to be better than it was. If you like that game, I would recommend www.ponystars.com. It is a better version of it.

Rating

PI is the best!
by: Love_stuff_stuff

Pony Island is completely addicting and is so totally fun! I can't stop playing! I love the site so much I have a T-Shirt that says PI Rocks!

Rating

Pony Island rocks
by: Megan P

Pony island is so good, I think it should be the best game in the WORLD!

Rating

Cool
by: Anonymous

Pony island is the best! I could play it all my life and my pony is having babies soon so I'm very happy. I'm so lucky to have a pony like star, she plays with me all the time and is good and looks very pretty.

Rating

Pony Island
by: Phoebe

It is hard to understand but when you have been playing it for a little bit, I bet you will understand. But it’s not half as good as howrse.

Rating

Pony Island is OK
by: Alyssa

I like it. I really do. But it isn't as fun as some other games.

Rating

Pony Island is the best
by: Lyssa

I think it's cool and maybe one day I can get me a pony like I always wanted to!

Rating

To play... or not to play?
by: Anonymous

To play... or not to play? That is the question. This game is fun for older kids, however I think that it is like many other games, where you do not actually get to do things physically. I personally think that it is a game of searching around the website; buying ponies, breeding ponies, etc. I would say for kids who are around the age of 13.

Rating

Horse owner
by: Anonymous

Having online horses are just as real as having a real horse. I have to feed my online horse horse everyday says my mom, if not I get grounded. And online competitions, I win a lot. My mom and dad always watch me and cheer me on.

Rating

The coolest game on the web
by: Samantha

I think pony island is the sweetest game ever, and I will play it for hours.

Rating

Pony Island
by: Anonymous

The game is alright, I have been on it before. I just don't have high-speed internet, so it did not work well, sniff.

Rating

Pony Island is cute
by: Lila

Pony Island is a cute game and this is the first time I tried it. I loved the ponies, even though they aren't realistic they are so pretty. Getting started is a little hard, I wish they had a video to tell you how to play! (There is so much to read.) But once you get going it is a good game.

Rating

Pony Island
by: Jesus&HorseLover4-ever

I think that the ponies look kinda weird! :P

Rating

LOVE IT!!!
by: Anonymous

I just love how cute the ponies are! I also like how you can do more than look at it's picture in the whole game.

Rating

Love it
by: Anonymous

I know it costs money but it's awesome. And if you have trouble buying ponies, click on their name. My username is fly1213. If you need help just pm me!

Rating

Uhh... I'm kinda confused...
by: Savanah

Umm... Kinda boring. I am new to Pony Island but it already seems kinda boring! I have a few questions. How do you get your pony to level 1? And how do you play games? If you know the answers, PLEASE answer! I'm Equusrgreat! PLEASE answer!

Rating

Love it!!
by: Anonymous

I really like this game. I found it very confusing at first, cos I was new. I don't get why this is a "paid" game, and if you don't pay, most privileges will be out of your reach. This isn't a game for younger kids cos I think it's a bit complicated. Older kids would understand better, that's my opinion.

Rating

I love it!
by: Country Horsegirl1

This game is so fun! A little confusing once you get started but if you just browse around then eventually you'll get the hang of it! :) (My user is CHorsegirl1)

Rating

Starving virtual horses
by: Anonymous

No offense, intended players can feel free to play games as they wish. I paid for a membership for my grandkids. It looks like a wonderful game for children who are older. I can not say it is a good game for younger children though.

The game pays players to feed their horses. Some players use this idea to make money with cull accounts. They have accounts where they buy virtual ponies and make a profit in game money starving them to death.

Yes, I know they are not real. My grandchildren who were 6 and 8 at the time were very upset with this and refused to play at all. This was a waste of my money. For adults and older children it would, I guess, be okay if they want to play.

Rating

Warning: Ponies can die!!!
by: Anonymous

As the father of a ten-year-old Horse-Crazy-Girl, I'd just like to say I've spent the last two hours consoling my daughter after her trial pony unexpectedly died! Apparently you can resurrect ponies once you start paying, but there's no way to resurrect a dead trial pony.

Rating

It's O.K.
by: Anonymous

I think this site is OK. I just started it and it makes me have to wait. Like I breed my one horse with this other one and now I have to wait 5 DAYS for the baby, and the horse I got in the beginning counted in actual days. Overall, it's OK. I still like Bella Sara better.

Rating

pony island
by: Anonymous

Kinda boring

Rating

Good BUT
by: Anonymous

It's awesome and so fun to make a pony but having too many accounts will ban you from their site! I would MUCH rather prefer bellasara.com! Try it!

Rating

I haven't played it yet
by: Anonymous

I haven't played it yet, but I want to. I just want some play tips, first. By what other people have written here, it looks awesome.

Rating

de
by: Anonymous

I couldn't figure it out

Rating

my ponyisland creator
by: Lexi

Who likes my pony island? Say I!

Rating

Randomness
by: Anonymous

I like the idea of the game, honestly, I do, but I don't like how you have to pay.

Click here to add your own comments

Return to Review Pony Island.